Programme Indexing Practices in Higher Education Institutions of Karnataka, India: Differences by Institution Type and Links with Accreditation Readiness and Governance Efficiency
Laxmi Sangapur *
Department of Education, Karnataka State Akkamahadevi Women University, Vijaypura, Karnataka, India.
Prakash K. Badiger
Department of Education, Regional Institute of Education (RIE), NCERT, Nellore, Andhra Pradesh, India.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Indian higher education institutions now report programme data to several national systems, including the All India Survey on Higher Education, the National Assessment and Accreditation Council and the Academic Bank of Credits. Little is known about how institutions keep the programme records that feed these systems. This study examined programme indexing, defined as the way an institution identifies, documents, digitally records, regulates and publishes information about its academic programmes, in 100 higher education institutions in Karnataka, 25 of each of four types. Different respondents within each institution completed the respective instruments: 256 academic administrators completed the Programme Indexing Practices Questionnaire–Revised (PIPQ-R), 241 faculty members completed the Academic Transparency Scale, 93 IQAC coordinators completed the Accreditation Readiness Scale, and 91 heads of institutions completed the Governance Efficiency Scale. The websites of 88 institutions (233 programmes) were also audited. Hypotheses were tested using institution-level mean scores. Programme indexing practices were moderate (M = 3.42 on a 1–5 scale) and differed by institution type, F(3, 95) = 4.33, p = 0.007, ω² = 0.09, with unaided colleges scoring below universities and autonomous colleges. Institutions with stronger practices reported higher accreditation readiness (r = 0.42) and governance efficiency (r = 0.31), and both relationships held after controlling for institution type. No relationship with academic transparency was found (r = −0.01), but faculty ratings of transparency did not reliably distinguish institutions. The weakest practices concerned sharing programme information with affiliating universities in a common format, updating digital records promptly, and keeping website information current; only 23% of institutions had a single web page listing all their programmes. The study concludes that most institutions hold the basic facts of their programmes but lack a single, current record shared across offices and with the affiliating university, and that such records are an overlooked part of the quality assurance infrastructure. It recommends a single programme register in every institution, maintained by a named office under a written policy; a common format for exchanging programme regulations between affiliating universities and colleges; standard programme fields in NAAC and national data platforms; and priority support for unaided colleges.
Keywords: Programme indexing, academic programme records, accreditation readiness, NAAC, data governance, higher education institutions, governance efficiency, digital academic records